News

| Submit CommentSubmit Comments | View CommentsView Comments(5)


advertisement

C-Charge anger of rebel MP

by Adam Derbyshire
29/10/2008

REBEL MP Andrew Gwynne has delivered a double whammy to the congestion charge.

He has joined a cross-party group of MPs campaigning for a ‘No’ vote in the referendum — and slammed changes to the charging zone as a token response to residents’ concerns.

Mr Gwynne is part of the Stop the Charge alliance, which also includes business and council leaders. MPs say the TIF proposals offer poor value for money and will unfairly penalise their constituents.

The Denton MP last month said he would not vote for the controversial scheme unless changes are made.

Transport chiefs have slightly re-routed the outer charge ring, which loosely follows the M60, to push the Snipe retail park and Lord Sheldon Way outside the charging zone.

Other amendments include:

  • A 20 per cent discount for people on the minimum wage.

  • A capped £5 maximum charge for anyone crossing the zones more than once at peak times.

  • Exemptions for disabled drivers, motorcyclists, hackney carriages, minicabs, emergency vehicles and anyone on their way to a medical appointment.

  • Bus fares will also be capped with set fares for short journeys and a standard fare for other trips.

    The amendments will be discussed at a crunch meeting of councils across Greater Manchester tomorrow (Friday).

    But Mr Gwynne’s solution that drivers would only pay the charge if they crossed both the outer and inner ring has been completely discarded.

    He said: "What really annoys me is AGMA have missed the opportunity to resolve the issue of local travel. They gave the impression they were about to make a major announcement about how the charge was going to work. Both myself and David Heyes were fully expecting them to run with the idea of only triggering the charge if motorists passed through both rings. The fact is people will still have to pay for driving from one side of Denton or Audenshaw to the other during peak times. That is wrong. How can they be causing congestion in Manchester city centre?

    "The Snipe is now free from the charge, but what about people making local journeys across Newmarket Road, Audenshaw Road, Windmill Lane, Lumb Lane or junction 24 of the M60,  Even with the discount for people on minimum wage, they will still have to pay £17 a week in order to get to work which wipes out the increase the government agreed just weeks ago. They are actually getting a pay cut. Congestion in Tameside is at its worst through the Longdendale villages and at junction 24 of the M60 in Denton. Nothing in the proposals will sort that out.

    "The charge should simply be triggered if you cross Mancunian Way or Trinity Way in the city centre. Instead we have the largest geographical charging zone in the world. It’s ridiculous."

    People will vote in a postal ballot in December on whether to accept the proposals. Voting papers are due to go out at the end of next month, with a voting deadline of 11 December. The bid would mean more than £2.75bn ploughed into transport schemes.


  • | Submit CommentSubmit Comments | View CommentsView Comments(5)


    Most recent 2 of 5 user comments

        I feel the important thing here is the actual congestion charge issue, if people have issues with Andrew Gwynnes views then fair enough,people can air their views at any time.First lets sort out this unfair and unjust charging scheme,In my mind its quite simple, if the Govt can bail out the uk banks (with our money!) to the tune of £150 billion plus, then they could quite easily sort out and improve public transport up and down the country, not just in Greater Manchester!I fear this is the thin end of the wedge, if this gets passed, it wont stop at this proposal. In Council documentation there is reference to potential future charging schemes in Oldham, Ashton, and Stockport to name but a few. Also the size of the congestion zone is absolutly ridiculous, 80 sqr miles, compared with the original London zone of 8 sqr miles! Can anyone tell me what traffic gridlock we have at daisy nook??and also what that has to do with congestion in Manchester city centre, because give or take 300 yards, thats where one part of the outer ring lies! Anyone passing over the motorway bridge on the way to littlemoss/Droylsden will potentially be charged! Further i have just recieved in the post a magazine with the `facts` relating to the proposals, i cant belive how one sided it is! I would urge the puplic, when your being bombarded with adverts in the press, posted at your home and workplace etc, just be wary,it seems to me they are pushing this too hard and people should be suspicious of this fact alone. Come on people, dont be fooled, think very carefully before you vote.
    kontraband, Tameside
    19/11/2008 at 20:56
       Now these objections to the Congestion Charge because of effects on his constituents is spin,because he supports the Mottram ByPass which will thrust another 35,000 daily vehicles into his Constituency where at present the traffic volumes are already 240,000 daily converging on the M67/M67/A57 throwing up the largest air pollution levels in Greater Manchester. No mention of that fight is there involving traffic,WHY NOT ?????
    J.Hall, Tameside
    5/11/2008 at 14:06
    Have your say
     
    Have your say Got an opinion you want to share?
    Register now and have your comments heard.

    Register now

    Personal Finance
     

    Balance Transfer
    Card BT Fee
    Virgin Credit Card 2.98%
    MBNA Platinum 2.9%
    Customers with a 'good' credit profile
    Company Typical APR
    Platinum Exclusive Loan 7.8%
    AA 7.9%
    Sainsbury's Personal Loan 8.2%
    Alliance & Leicester 8.7%
    Lloyds TSB 8.9%
    Abbey Personal Loan 8.9%
    HASH(0x2ada01f42d60)
    Provider AER*
    ICICI BANK
    HiSAVE Savings Account
    4.50%
    FIRST DIRECT
    Everyday e-Saver
    1.75%
    SAINSBURYS FINANCE
    Internet Saver
    2.25%